• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Penny's Coffee Shop

At Penny's Coffee Shop, located at 916 Main St, Buffalo, NY, we craft an unforgettable breakfast and brunch experience. Our journey began with a passion for quality, cozy ambiance, and community connection. With offerings like our acclaimed lox bagel and comforting avocado toast, every dish is made with fresh ingredients and a Mediterranean twist. Guests rave about our friendly staff and charming decor, making it an ideal spot for indulgent pastries like baklava and delicious lattes. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a leisurely morning with friends, Penny's is where flavor and comfort meet, creating a warm and inviting haven for all.

LOCATIONS

Welcome to the charming world of Penny's Coffee Shop, nestled on 916 Main St in Buffalo, NY. With a delightful menu that caters to breakfast, brunch, and dessert enthusiasts, this cozy eatery strikes the perfect balance between comfort and culinary creativity. Whether you're an early riser or someone looking for a leisurely brunch, Penny's is the ideal spot to start your day.

About Penny's Coffee Shop
At Penny's, the inviting aroma of freshly brewed coffee greets you at the door. The atmosphere is warm, setting the stage for a peaceful dining experience. Patrons often rave about the friendly staff who are eager to assist you in navigating the delightful menu.

  • Breakfast Sandwiches and Toasts: Begin your day with options like the Smoked Salmon Toast, perfectly complemented by cream cheese and capers, or the vibrant Avocado Toast, rich in flavor and topped with fresh ingredients. These dishes are not just meals but an experience in every bite.
  • Pastries & Desserts: Indulge your sweet tooth with freshly baked treats such as buttery croissants and decadent tiramisu. The Baklava, with its flaky layers and sweet honey syrup, is a must-try for any dessert lover.

Many customers have shared glowing reviews about their experiences at Penny's. One delighted patron, Anano N., described the lox bagel as "one of the best I have ever had," highlighting the shop's ability to impress with its simple yet splendid offerings. The positive feedback extends to the assorted beverages as well, such as the smooth Chai Latte and a variety of lattes perfect for both coffee aficionados and novices alike.

Adding to the experience is the cozy decor, which features charming swings and colorful signage, creating a perfect backdrop for your morning coffee or a leisurely read of your favorite book. The ambiance invites patrons to unwind and enjoy their culinary adventure.

In conclusion, Penny's Coffee Shop is more than just a place to grab a bite; it's a cozy haven where food, coffee, and community converge. With a menu designed to please a range of tastes and dietary needs, it's no wonder this Buffalo gem has garnered dedicated patrons who recommend it without hesitation. Whether stopping in for a quick breakfast or savoring a leisurely brunch with friends, Penny's promises to deliver delicious memories each visit.

So why not take a moment to indulge your senses and experience the delightful offerings of Penny's Coffee Shop? Your taste buds will undoubtedly thank you!

START YOUR REVIEW OF Penny's Coffee Shop
Anano N.
Anano N.

I was at Penny's coffee shop the other morning and it was such a delightful experience. The staff were super friendly and nice; they were kind enough to take their time and explain their menu to me. I got a matcha latte and a lox bagel. Trust me, the lox bagel was one of the best I have ever had in my life. The atmosphere is super calm and cozy. 10/10 would definitely recommend!

Brielynn B.
Brielynn B.

Penny's is such a fun spot! Located right in the heart of the city, I like to stop here on my way to work occasionally or I stop in for a solo date with a book, and it's super cozy. My go to drink is always a latte with either caramel or vanilla, however I do switch up on what I get to eat. So far, I've tried a plain bagel toasted with butter, an everything bagel with cream cheese, their double chocolate chip muffin and their chocolate chip cookies. My favorite item? The plain bagel toasted with butter! I don't know how they get the butter to soak so perfectly into the bagel, but oh my goodness, it's amazing. The employees are always super friendly and I think it's just a great spot to kick off your day. Plus, it's so cute inside that you can take some really fun photos.

Jasmine J.
Jasmine J.

The sugar free Carmel latte with a sprinkle of cinnamon was great. The espresso was rich and smooth. Came back the next day to order food and kill some time. That's when I discovered the swings. I just love the swings and the decorations are cute. The cashier was nice and personable. Nothing amazing but also nothing bad. If you're in the neighborhood stop by.

Brandon G.
Brandon G.

In my new search, I am looking for a great chai latte in the city. I think I have found a really great one at Penny's. As someone who doesn't like coffee, I never knew what to order from coffee shops when I met people there. I would usually just get food or an iced tea. Now I know about chai, so it's a whole new world of tastes. The chai latte here was great. Sometimes when you get them, they taste plain. But not here! There were flavors of cinammon and vanilla in this that made it delicious. I followed it up with a banana walnut muffin that was too good to get it's photo beforehand. This coffee shop has such a great vibe to it. I can sit here and work on my computer for a while and feel cozy with plenty of food and drink options. The staff here is very friendly and will help you with the menu if you don't know what you're feeling. Definitely a spot to come back to again and again.

Samantha C.
Samantha C.

Penny's is a great little coffee shop in Allentown near the medical campus. It seems to be a comfortable place to do a little work or visit with friends. They have traditional coffee and tea drinks and a variety of breakfast and lunch sandwiches and pastries. Many dishes have a Mediterranean regional cuisine twist. Our favorite items are the lox bagels, the BLT with garlic sauce sandwich, and the pistachio latte made with pistachio milk. What a fabulous drink the pistachio latte is. You should try one immediately. The shop is clean and has cute decor and colorful signage displaying the menu items and specials.

Robert B.
Robert B.

Penny's Coffee Shop in Buffalo, NY, is a true gem! The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the aroma of freshly brewed coffee hits you as soon as you step inside. The staff is not only friendly but also knowledgeable, especially when it comes to their impressive selection of wines. It's a fantastic bonus that they offer expert recommendations! Located conveniently right around the corner from my job, it's the perfect spot for a quick coffee break. Don't forget to sign up for their rewards system at checkout--it's a great way to earn perks with every visit. I can't recommend Penny's enough; I'm already looking forward to my next trip!

Raina A.
Raina A.

4.5/5 I got the iced caramel apple tea latte which was absolutely DELICIOUS!! Not too sweet and a perfect blend of flavours. Tasted like autumn! about $5.50 I also got the lox bagel which was amazing. I knocked half a star because it could have used more salmon but nonetheless it was absolutely delicious! $11 The interior is sooo cute! Great cafe!

Daviyion J.
Daviyion J.

Came by for a work meeting and stayed to grab a bite. I wanted to sample a bit of what they had to offer so I got a sandwich, blueberry muffin, and a hot beverage. Everything was really delicious.l! Not being a huge coffee drinker, I got one of their seasonal 'spring fever' drinks, which was called 'Cup of Sunshine'. This was a house-made Golden milk that was sweetned with honey. The chicken pesto panini ($14.95) was very delicious and came with chicken pesto, sun-dried tomatoes, and mozzarella on focaccia bread. It came with a little salad as well. And the blueberry muffin ($3.50)was a large delicious blueberry muffin, haha! I also really enjoyed the overall atmosphere of the place and it had a variety of seating options, including a pair of porch swings (probably not the best for drinking a hot coffee though lol)

Vicky B.
Vicky B.

Came here for breakfast on a Sunday and enjoyed the smoked salmon toast and coffee. Everything about the toast was delicious! The atmosphere here is also very welcoming and cute, with table seating, seating along the window, and an adjacent room that's a cute space for a photo op. Ordering was quick but it took my food quite a while to come out. However they were very busy that day which may have been the reason why my food took awhile.